|
YOGASON
The
ethical discipline® |
|
READ
BELOW
What Descartes,
Malebranche, Spinoza and Leibniz said on Mind & Body: |
|
PERIOD
|
PHILOSOPHERS
|
VIEWS
|
|
CA
800 BCE
|
INDIAN
PHILOSOPHERS
|
Body
is only an instrument used by consciousness, while consciousness is
not the product of the body.
Body
and mind are one vital unity – they are a whole but at the same time
unchangeably different – each is acting on the other, but not
derived from each other.
They
recognized a close connection of mind and body - A psychophysical
phenomenon.1
|
| 1596
– 1650 CE
|
RENE
DESCARTES
|
In
his book “Meditations”, he wrote, “the act of understanding is
distinguished from that of the imagination.
The human mind is shown to
be really distinct from the body, and, nevertheless, to be so closely
conjoined therewith, as together to form, as it were, a unity."
According to him, mind is diametrically opposed to body. Mind is
active and free though the mind influences the body and the body also
influences the mind, i.e. they interact with each other.
These
two substances mind and body are created by God.
|
| 1638
– 1715 CE
|
MALEBRANCHE
|
Malebranche
wrote in 1674 in his publication “De la recherché de la verite”
that God is the one and only true cause.
Not only is there no
influence of mind on body or body on mind, there is no causality
operative at all except in so far as God, The One True Cause,
intervene to produce the regularities that occur in experience.
|
| 1632
– 1677 CE
|
SPINOZA
|
Spinoza’s
theory was based on the notion that the mental & physical are
simply different aspects of one and the same substance.
For
Spinoza, the single substance was god.
Although the personal survival
after death is an illusion, there is nevertheless something in the
human mind that is eternal.
The mind can only imagine or remember
while the body endures, but there is in God an idea, which expresses
the essence of this or that human body under the form of eternity, and
this idea is the eternal part of the mind.
2
|
| 1646
– 1716 CE
|
LEIBNIZ
|
The
German historian, mathematician, philosopher, scientist and diplomat
presented the famous articulation of psychophysical parallelism that
soul and body exist in a pre-established harmony.
Comparing soul and
body to two clocks that agree perfectly. Parallelism – The Notion
That Mind And Body Exist In Harmony That Has Been Pre-Established By
God From The Moment Of Creation.
Leibniz held that every soul mirrors
the universe, not because the universe affects it, but because God has
given it a nature, which spontaneously produces this result.
His contention that “our inner world is richer, ampler and
more concealed,” was well known to the Indian writers of the
Upanisads. 1
|
Source: www.
serendip.brynmawr.edu
1. Indian Philosophy by
Radhakrishnan
2.
History of Western Philosophy by Bertrand Russell
|
|